What Is a Plea Agreement?

A plea agreement is a deal between the prosecutor and the defense to resolve a criminal charge without going to trial. Usually the defendant agrees to plead guilty to a lower or related charge, and in exchange the prosecutor agrees to something such as dismissing other charges or recommending a particular sentence. People also call it a plea bargain or a plea deal.

What is a plea agreement in practice? It depends heavily on the case. Not every case leads to an offer, and the terms of one agreement can look very different from another. A plea agreement also isn’t final until a judge approves it.

How does a plea agreement work in Missouri?

In Missouri, plea agreements are negotiated between the prosecuting attorney and the defense attorney, or the defendant if they’re representing themselves. Missouri Supreme Court Rule 24.02 governs the process.

The judge doesn’t take part in those negotiations. Once the two sides have reached an agreement, it’s presented to the court, and the judge decides whether to accept it. The court also has to confirm that the defendant understands the plea, is entering it voluntarily, and that there’s a factual basis for it.

Most plea discussions happen after the defense has had a chance to review the state’s evidence. An early offer may change as the case develops.

What can be included in a plea agreement?

Missouri’s rule recognizes a few basic kinds of agreements, plus a catch all for other appropriate dispositions.

Charges

The prosecutor may agree to amend a charge to a different or lesser offense, or to dismiss one or more charges, in exchange for a guilty plea to another. Whether that’s possible depends on the case and on what the prosecutor is willing to offer.

Sentencing recommendations

The prosecutor may agree to recommend a particular sentence, or not to oppose the defense’s request for one. That’s a recommendation, and the judge isn’t required to follow it. The judge should tell you on the record that you can’t withdraw your plea if the recommendation isn’t followed.

An agreed sentence

The prosecutor and defense may instead agree that a specific sentence is the appropriate outcome. This kind of agreement works differently, because if the judge decides not to follow it, the defendant generally has the right to take back the plea.

The difference between those last two matters a great deal. More on that below.

Does accepting a plea agreement mean pleading guilty?

In most cases, yes. A plea agreement usually involves entering a guilty plea to at least one charge. A guilty plea generally results in a conviction, just as a guilty verdict after trial would.

That said, a negotiated plea doesn’t always end in a conviction on your record. In Missouri, one possible outcome is a suspended imposition of sentence, or SIS, where the judge places the defendant on probation without entering a sentence. Whether that’s available, and whether it’s offered, depends on the charge and the circumstances. It shouldn’t be assumed. An SIS can also be revoked if probation is violated, and some Missouri laws treat a guilty plea with an SIS like a conviction for certain purposes, meaning probation would be violated.

Entering a plea also means giving up certain rights, including the right to a trial, the right to confront the state’s witnesses, and the right not to testify against yourself. The judge will go over these before accepting the plea.

Can someone reject a plea agreement?

Yes. The decision whether to plead guilty belongs to the defendant.

Turning down an offer doesn’t mean the case goes straight to trial. Negotiations may continue, motions may be filed, and the case moves through its other stages. But an offer that’s been rejected may not come back, and a later offer may be different. Neither accepting nor rejecting an offer guarantees a better result.

What to understand before accepting a plea agreement

Before entering a plea, it’s important to know exactly what you’re agreeing to. That means knowing which charge you’d be pleading guilty to, what sentence or conditions are likely, and what the plea would mean for your criminal record.

It also means knowing which kind of agreement it is. If the prosecutor is only recommending a sentence, the judge can impose something different, and in Missouri you generally can’t withdraw your plea just because the judge didn’t follow the recommendation. If the agreement involves a specific sentence or a change to the charges and the judge rejects it, you’re generally given the chance to withdraw the plea.

A conviction can also have consequences outside the courtroom. These can affect a driver’s license, a job, professional licensing, or firearm rights. They depend on the offense and the person, so they’re worth asking about before you decide, not after.

Is a plea agreement better than going to trial?

There’s no general answer. It depends on the strength of the state’s evidence, whether there are real legal or factual defenses, what the offer actually is, and what could happen at trial.

For some people, a plea agreement offers a more predictable outcome. For others, the evidence or the defenses make it worth taking the case further. A trial doesn’t guarantee an acquittal, and a plea doesn’t guarantee a light sentence. The decision should be based on the facts of the case, not on pressure to get it over with or a refusal on principle.

How a criminal defense attorney can help

A defense attorney reviews the charges and the evidence before an offer is evaluated. That way, the offer can be compared with what the state can actually prove. The attorney explains the terms in plain language, including what kind of agreement it is and what the judge can and can’t do with it. They also point out consequences you may not have thought about.

What an attorney can’t do is control what the prosecutor offers or what the judge decides. The final choice to accept or reject a plea is yours.

If you’ve been charged or have received a plea offer, Schmanke Law Firm provides criminal defense representation for people throughout East Central Missouri.

—

Have a Question About Your Situation?

Every case is different. Talk with an attorney at Schmanke Law about what this means for you. Your first consultation is free.

Union Office

Owensville Office

Legal Disclaimer
The information on this website is for general purposes only and is not legal advice. Contacting Schmanke Law does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome in your case.

This website is designed for general information only. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements. The information on this website should not be construed to be legal advice or the formation of an attorney/client relationship.

© 2026 Schmanke Law Office LLC. All rights reserved.

Previous
Previous

When Can Child Support Be Modified?

Next
Next

What Happens When Someone Dies Without a Will?